Hey Gary,
i see your problem. I see the same things as you, but....i don't feel like leaving myself. Sure, i don't want to start my own guild, but i honestly thinkg every guild has the same problems. many not playfull players.
but (no offense) see how many recruiting you do atm? same for me or Kivra..all officers.
the only person in the guild that we can honestly say that recruits is Olorin. So when you start your own guild that means lots of recruiting. recruitfull officers and helpfull officers.
What i want to say...starting your own guild does not solve the problem of leavers.. The only thing you can do is to recruit 10 persons each day.. 1 of them will stay and play a lot.
You can do that in the bloody dragoons guild or in your own.. I prefer you staying, but if you really feel like leaving...follow your heart and i hope you will be fine.
If you want to change the guild....start recruiting. I promise i will take my part as well. I am not that good in it, but try to get at least 1 or 2 persons each day..that will revive our guild again.
So i hope i can see new members tomorrow :-)
I am not so good in explaining in english, but none of above is meant rude...
Amy